Rushdie on atheism

Salman Rushdie has an article in TheStar.com: Just give me that old-time atheism! (via Arts & Letters.) I’ve not read any of his books, so I was interested in seeing what he had to say. Unfortunately, he has just as simplistic and limited a world-view as that which he is skewering:

It is among the truths believed to be self-evident by the followers of all religions that godlessness is equivalent to amorality and that ethics requires the underpinning presence of some sort of ultimate arbiter, some sort of supernatural absolute, without which secularism, humanism, relativism, hedonism, liberalism and all manner of permissive improprieties will inevitably seduce the unbeliever down immoral ways.

All religions, you say? Harumph.

I ended up suspecting Rushdie of being one of those writers who believes that being uniformly critical (without offering any solution, suggestion, or resolution), if done with great style, makes for successful writing.

Book Meme

Rivertyde has tagged me for the current book meme. Here are the four questions and my answers:

What is the total number of books I’ve owned? Well now, that’s extremely hard to say. I currently own around 600 books. But my book-buying life has spanned, in addition to the regular across-town moves to a new house or apartment, a move from college in Davis, California, to San Francisco; a move from SF to Philadelphia; and a move from Philly to Boston. The SF-to-Philadelphia and Philadelphia-to-Boston moves were particularly hard on the book collection. I also weed periodically. My guess is that I’ve owned at least 3,000 books.

What was the last book I bought? Literally, the last book I bought was Russell the Sheep by Rob Scotton, a picture book for ages 3–7 that I bought for my 18-month-old nephew, Russell. The last book I bought for myself was a three-book splurge: Migration: Species Imperative #2, by Julie E. Czerneda; Elantris, by Brandon Sanderson; and Building Harlequin’s Moon, by Larry Niven and Brenda Cooper.

What was the last book I read? That would be Elantris.

Five books that mean a lot to me: What a tough question–“that mean a lot” is really different from “that I like a lot.” Here’s today’s attempt at an answer:

A Description of the Qualifications Necessary to a Gospel Minister by Samuel Bownas. Advice from an eighteenth-century Quaker minister and elder. An important factor in my spiritual formation.

Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien. The epitome of epic, stylish fantasy, the struggle between good and evil carried forward by the humble. Oddly enough, The Silmarillion is a real contender to take this spot.

The Bible. What can I say? Although it’s used to justify all manner of evil, it’s also a sourcebook for liberation movements and the foundational (though now often neglected) text for my religious tradition.

A Wizard of Earthsea by Ursula K. LeGuin. OK, adolescent self-discovery won out over the psychological insight or gender ambiguities of other titles by this great writer.

In This House of Brede by Rumer Godden. Ask me about my past life as a nun sometime.

Tag, you’re it: Beppe, Philocrites (or maybe this would be more up the alley of Pseudophilocrites), Doc Smartypants, Not-so-fresh (feel free to reply here in the comments since this is way off-topic over there at tamponblog; or maybe bitch and snark need to get a jump on things), and Velveteen Rabbi. For good measure, I’ll also toss it over to Brian.

Elantris by Brandon Sanderson

Brandon Sanderson’s first published novel, Elantris, is an engaging, stylish fantasy novel. The cover blurbs make much of the fact that it’s a “complete and thoroughly satisfying story in a single volume.” And it is that, although at the very end there are a couple of hints that the author might have other books in mind. I certainly hopes he returns to this world and these characters. I’d heartily recommend this book.

Migration: Species Imperative #2 by Julie Czerneda

I loved Julie Czerneda’s first “species imperative” book, and I loved Migration: Species Imperative #2. I was delighted to find on Czerneda’s website that there’s a third due out in a year. This volume actually does an ok job of ending at a point where you’re not desperate for the next one, but it’s also clear what the third one will be about. The cover art, by the way, has nearly no connection to the contents. You can always put a plain brown wrapper on the book or remove the jacket!

The Bean Trees by Barbara Kingsolver

The Bean Trees is the first book I read by Barbara Kingsolver, and I was pleased to reread it recently for my book group. There were things I missed the first time (or had forgotten), and the conversation we had was very rich.

I had always thought of Taylor as the ultimate no-nonsense, competent person who can cope with anything. But as we discussed the book, I realized she isn’t really much good at coping until she’s had time to retreat from the crisis and then return to it. Discovering a new angle on a character is one of the joys both of rereading and of discussing books.

Survival: Species Imperative #1

Julie E. Czerneda’s Survival: Species Imperative #1 is a real page-turner of a sci-fi book. Without reading like a heavy, self-important book, it raises deep questions about friendship, survival, and science. Czerneda was trained as a biologist, and it shows in her writing. There’s a sequel out, and I’m eager to get it.

The Little Guide to Your Well-Read Life by Steve Leveen

Steve Leveen’s The Little Guide to Your Well-Read Life sort of belongs in the goofy, slight, self-help category of books. But because he did actually talk to a wide range of avid readers, his summary of reading advice includes a few helpful ideas that are new to me (as well as some already familiar ones).

The first (and biggest) new idea is creating a list of candidates for reading, grouped under headings, with notes about when and why they were added. Leveen suggests there are too many books to read and that you should pay attention to what your interests are and seek to find the best books that reflect your interests. (He’s also an advocate for abandoning books that just aren’t doing it for you.) He links this suggestion to keeping a list of the books you’ve read (obviously not a new idea for me).

The obvious categories for my list of candidates included Time Travel, Speculative Fiction, Biography, Natural History, Horticulture, Botany, and Taxonomy.

Leveen suggests buying books and shelving them by the same categories so they are ready to hand when you’re looking for something to read. After he’s read books, he puts them on an intermediate shelf where he can easily pick them up to review what he learned or noted from each book before moving them into what he calls his “Living Library.”

In order to get more from reading, he suggests surveying the book before beginning to read, writing in the margins (especially questions to yourself), and reviewing the book at increasing intervals after you finish.

He includes chapters on audio books and book groups.

All in all, a worthwhile read.

Discovering Your Personality Type

Discovering Your Personality Type by Don Richard Russo and Russ Hudson was my capitulation to finding out about the Enneagram. Several friends rave about it, and my housemate has been to several training institutes. So I caved. Interesting book, a bit rah-rah and “buy our books” for my taste, but having taken their instrument and looking at my office through the Enneagram lens, it looks useful.

Here’s their website: Enneagram Institute: Enneagram Testing & Training.

And if you’re curious: active five with a four wing.

Gay marriage anniversary

Yesterday was the first anniversary of legal same-sex marriages in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. The Unitarian Univeraslist Association had a lovely reception for the plaintiff couples in the legal suit that brought about the equalization of marriage. Six of the seven couples were able to attend, as well as Mary Bonauto, the lawyer who represented them, and staff and volunteers from Mass Equality and Freedom to Marry, two civil rights groups here in Boston. Yummy cake, yummy cheese, and bubbly champagne–all smack dab in the middle of a work afternoon–then we trouped out to Boston Common for a photo op with the State House in the background.

For a more political and strategic take on the day, I liked what AndrewSullivan had to say:

Above all, we have changed consciousness. In civil rights movements, that’s what matters and that’s what endures. People forget that two decades ago, homosexuality meant simply sex for most Americans–and unsavory sex at that. Or it meant counter-cultural revolution. Or left-wing victim politics. By fighting the marriage fight, we changed the terms of that debate. We co-opted the language of our enemies–the language of family, love, responsibility, commitment. We did this not simply because it helps us win over the middle of American politics. But because it’s actually reflective of the reality of many of our lives.

The Whole Hog by Lyall Watson

I was concerned that The Whole Hog: Exploring the Extraordinary Potential of Pigs, by Lyall Watson, might potentially put me off my pork products, but it didn’t quite manage that. It did, however, come close. Watson describes several personal relationships with pigs–none of which happen to be your garden-variety meat hog, which is why I suspect I got away with my dietary sensibilities relatively intact. (I do, however, struggle with weaning myself from animal products produced by industrial agriculture.)